Yesterday saw the big annual jamboree for the Fabian Society, one of the oldest and largest think-tank organisations in the country. It has had an interesting history on the left of British politics, sometimes being at the heart of new policy generation and sometimes being a home for dissidents.
These days, it is less interesting than either of those trends. Reports of their event suggest it was well attended, with many leading Labour ministers taking part on the platform. The problem was that with that input came an insistence on New Labour-like control. Discussions that looked like they might have been taken off message by members of the audience, were quickly curtailed. James Purnell (Secretary of State for Work and Pensions) talked about redistribution, but ignored a direct question on whether that would mean tax rises; which were clearly a good thing in the eyes of the questioner. More incredibly, Purnell walked away from a lady who came up to him afterwards to ask an awkward question about Heathrow. He listened to her for about thirty seconds before just walking off saying she was not interested in listening to him. No, she wasn’t. But he should have been interested in listening to her. It was an extraordinarily high-handed way to behave.
Purnell had said some other interesting things, it seems. He admitted that “the right” do care about other people (which was me by gasps from the audience) but, rightly, pointed out that the difference is often the role of the state in resolving issues. He also observed that thirty-years ago, the “Winter of Discontent” had shaped the politics of a generation, leading them to accept Thatcher’s reforms and he seemed to hope that current crisis would swing the pendulum Labour’s way again. Not quite as insensitive as Baroness Vadera’s comments last week… but close.
This theme was echoed by Rushanara Ali, Labout PPC for Bethnal Green. She argued that Labour (“we…”) need to make the most of the current “opportunity”. She acknowledge the need for markets (very open minded of her) but thought that it would be appropriate to highlight the failings of “the Thatcherite-Reagen consensus”, which she argued has been “destroyed”. Funnily enough, there was no mention of Brown’s economic excess or the ten years Labour has had to make amends if he had wished.
In their fantasies, the Fabians had wished the last ten years away. We could have agreed with that dream.
At least there was one Labour minister that did not seem to be living in a dream land. Douglas Alexander, Secretary of State for International Development, made one financial observation that had nothing to do with the current economic crisis. When talking about party-funding, he dryly observed, that,
“If there is a party that is obsessed with money, it is not the Conservative Party.” Absolutely, Douglas. He still drifted back to the idea, though, that the current economic woes are of Tory-doing rather than Labour’s, though, with his comment that, “the right is intellectually bankrupt in the face of what has happened in the last eight months… it is up to the left…”.
Such fantasies are truly of staggering scale.